A Dynamic Oligopoly Structural Model for the Prescription Drug Market ... [PDF]

A Dynamic Oligopoly Structural Model for the Prescription Drug Market After Patent Expiration. Andrew T. Ching. *. Unive

9 downloads 14 Views 455KB Size

Recommend Stories


Coopetition in a Mixed Oligopoly Market
If you want to go quickly, go alone. If you want to go far, go together. African proverb

Prescription Drug Reimbursement Form
Ego says, "Once everything falls into place, I'll feel peace." Spirit says "Find your peace, and then

medicare prescription drug benefit
What you seek is seeking you. Rumi

Sample Prescription Drug Report
How wonderful it is that nobody need wait a single moment before starting to improve the world. Anne

Prescription Drug Cost Sharing
What you seek is seeking you. Rumi

2018 Prescription Drug List
Be who you needed when you were younger. Anonymous

Prescription Drug Benefits
You're not going to master the rest of your life in one day. Just relax. Master the day. Than just keep

Prescription Drug Importation
Pretending to not be afraid is as good as actually not being afraid. David Letterman

2016 Prescription Drug List
If you want to go quickly, go alone. If you want to go far, go together. African proverb

2017 Prescription Drug List
Be who you needed when you were younger. Anonymous

Idea Transcript


                        

             



                   

 

                       !     "      

             

#            $   

    

       

       %  &          '(('      &        '(('

             

)   

 &  *    +  ,       -  ../( 0      + 123(4,.252   6

                                                                                   !"#                

           $% & '()

           

      



  

                                                      #                                           *                          +           ,       

 

   -./ %     $  , 0 #)         

+      1  -./        2                            ,                                +  

        

   .3        $4   &/.( %

 0 & 5(     2&6-()

          ./    

      7                     +   1       

                $ %   & 6( *    8&6 (&65( 4   &/-( !  4 &59( *    % &66( %& .(  % & :(); $)             < $)                  

         #   $ *    8&6 (  !  4 &5'(&59()  =                  <  % & '(                      ,                                         

  

                                      

                4                         <                                 ,     $     



+   71.8       

 9  

 ,        

         

    

 

 ,  :

    ,                       ;        

        "                                 "                 -./ , 0 #   !"#   

                             -./  -.9          $>Æ 

   #  &:3()

         

            $  &/ () #                       +                      

      

      !"#               *    8&63(                      ?@"          ,             .3                                             

        +   

           

4 &/'(         A          , 4 &/'(                                                              B +                   #  

              !"#      + 

               !"#

             

      

               #             +                                  ?  0 &//(              ,            

5

         

     

                                   !"#

       

           4 &/9(  C

   C

 &5 (                #                              

                         ?    &/:( D &/3(  #  2  ,  E

 &6(                #  C    E

 &/( , &6/(  F

  ? &6'(                       

     2

 8G G&9( &.(                            +          

          

               

            7          ,      

                

     

             #                 

         

 "              $ C  F&56( # & (  %  4 & -() 

        

                                           

   +                     C   1 &5/(  1  *&/5(&/6( "                  Æ             

 

         

     $ *   &5-(  2&'() >               

       !   1 &5:( * &5.(  %   E& /(                       

6

         +   #   2&'(    +                                        2       C  F&56(      

                                         ,       !"#    

 

      7                

     !"#    !                !    H       +                     

          2    !               

 +         B C+  

                   



          $% & '()                                  

                                                      ,                 B                                               *               IJ     I  J  % +            

         

                     +      ,       

            

  4 5                    4 6                          +  

/

 4 /                         4 :        

         

 



 

 

                      !"#     

   #  B " #  $#B"#)                                  + 

           

       !"#  +  "                                                            

     +      H   H   

                            !"#   #B"#                        

      

    #

                   

  

                    

                 #B"#                  

 

 

              4      !"# 

     $4 &/'()

             

                    4          7                    !"#                    !"#    

- .5/         ?

     



A



             =  $  

>

? @







B  >                

-

     



    > ??  >  Æ  ?

     $             )< $ )              





4              +        

                                                          #      

        $) L

           

     $) L 3      



 $) L 

        

  $)     $    )   I J   $3)

  

           +               D  $)                       

                  $D &69() #  C  F&56(                          

         

      

  ;

 &   $)( L

    M  &  $)(   &  $)(   $Æ M  $)) M 



M M   

$-)

   &   $)(                   <

           <              <       Æ<                <                   < $ M   )                         

% 



Æ

 

     :

"  7.48



         

Æ

 :$ 

  

         ,        ,       C    

     

3

                     C 7  =         



                 4                   

                                         !        

                 !6

$

)



    

    C 8   

 $ M   )     C 8    $

) !6



> 

              C 8                           $-) ,                        $) L 3 

 &  $)( L    L 3

 

                          

 &  $)( L " M "  M K 

$ 3)

  K L  M                       

                   

             

      Æ $"  " )     #  ,  4&6:(             Æ $ )    Æ        $"  " )       #        I  J             

       $D    $                

"  7.48    C :           

  







  

 

  

Æ                 

        



    

    

   Æ  >    ? 



  $            " 7.(8



   $  "  " )

           

 

            #    2  1 &-(  #   ? &5(          $  7 )             



                                 



                                

              

                $4O1")           



            

                 



    

 4O1"                                $% & :()    

      



         4O1"

           

$ )  $ )

L N  #$$ )

$

  N           

         





)

   

              

  

      +         

            A                        #                       ,                                                                                     

% 

 7  > ?8  

        

            

           E 7'8 %   &   7''8    

F ;G           





     F   G          

  :                 

5







          

    ; $ )           $5)               

                              ; $ )            $5)           !"#     $6)                       %  7            ,       $  4 &/9( 4 &/'()          

                                             !"#                   !"#7    $        =     )                                                 

        

 

          

             

          

        

          #                  #      

    !"#               D          $          !"#   )

                 $          !"#7  )   % L  &  $)(  $)          L $   )                      D & $ <   )               

          

6

 



D       K L $  

   )         

                        

                

                       

$  $ ) L 3  &  $ )( L  )



?

           D K  

     



     

   '    L 

      7

    ;

( $% ) L

 & $%    K     )

 

M 

 & $ <  



 

( $% ) L



  M ) &( $% )%   $  K     )  L  (( $ 5)

 & $%    K     )(

 

                        $  )          $ &  $ M )()    $ $ M ))         $ ) D K $ ) L $  $ )

   $ ))          

    4 

        $ &  $)(  $)  )  

   +                $ ) L  $ )   L



   B       7  

      7

      7                

      

% 

 



 >H    ?

  7 

 +      

     > 7

 > ?8  ?

      

                  

0        :$        

          



   

  

    

          

       :   D              

     :   D       

/

 7      K     K $ )

( $% ) L

 & $%    K $ ))

 

 & $<

M 

 



 

( $% ) L



  M ) &( $% )%   $  K $ ))  L  (( $ 6)

 & $%    K $ ))(

 

4                             $ 5)  $ 6)               %   $%     ) $  &  $ M )(   )

     

                  

            L  M            $ M ) L  L               

  

   Æ



    $C+ $.)) ?

                 

  C+ $:);

 &  $ M )( L  &  $)( M  $)$N   &  $)()  +                         "        "$ &  $ M )( $)  )     7               

 &( $% )%     L  <  ( L

  

( $% %     ) "$ &  $ M )( $)  ) ) $ )

$ /)

  )          4                             D )            

 &( $% )%     L  ( L



 &( $% )%     L  <  ( ) $ )

 $ :)

                                           $ /)  :

$ :) 4             &( $% )%     L  (    

             6/

          B            $      )

 

                       $3))                    $ )   $  

         +

                                    $ )



#                  

     

    "               %K L %        *                              ;

( $%K   L *) L  

& 

 



$ *  L ) &( $% )%   L 3  L  (

$ ')

  & $ * )            !"#              + 

   +                

 $  )  ;

 $%K ) L

 3  (

%K   L )     * ;  ( $%K   L *) ( $%K   L * M ) '    $

$ 9)

B    7        $%K )        ( 

 

    +  $%K )



      

                      +     ?                  



                           

   :                       $             

        

'

>                        $ 2&'()

 

                  

 $)                &  $)(    

 &  $)( L



   

  $) L



  

   

$ .)

  

$ -)

 

 '  '

'  

$53)

3 L  '  '

' 

$5 )

 $)     C+ $.) ?

  

 +     

  !                             $)          K



 $3) L   $3)            K 

 $ M )    $)     $.) B     $ M )            K  

     

 $ M ) D                          

          



 $ M )     

 $ M )          K

 $)      

 ; K 

  K $ M

  )L  









   

 

       

    



   

$55)



B 7              &( $% )%   $  K $ ))

 L  <  ( 

 ,     C+ $ /) %   &  $)(     &  $ M



)(  

     $:)       ;

  &  $ M )(  L $ (   &  $ M )( 

 $)) &  $)( M  $)   L  $) Æ 

$56)



$5/)

B        

    &  $ M )(       

K &  $M )(       

    

               

                  

9



I  ?  > 

  

 

    L

 





                  

  

 

 ;

& -$ ) L P$ )  P$  )   L

  

& -$ ) L P$  ) & -$ ) L



$5:) $5')

P$ 



 )

$59)

  P$ )       &  $ M )(    &  $)(    !    7           $ )    

        

K &  $ M )(           

 &( $% )%     <  ( L

 & -$& 

 $ M )( L  )(N $ &  $ M )(%     <  )





$5.)

 

(N $ &  $ M )(%     <  ( L



& -$K  $ M ) L  )( $% %     <  )

$5-)



 



 , 

         $5:)  $59)          +   $    ) B                   $ $   ))         

 2 

              



           

  

  

 

 ,       

        4                    !

    * , +    &( $% )%     L  <  ( 

     &( $% )%     L  ( $C+ $ :)) 

  

           



J

.



            





       ; +      +       4 $4)           #  $1#) #B"#      !  " #  $!"#)      4            B #    % 4    B ,  "   4 

   +

                  +

                         5:          % & '(

  

          ; 

                % & '(             %                            

 H+

            633      



!  

                        ;  &  $)(           

         

 

     

          



              +            % & '(                  

        $  

      )

 % & '(            

         

     D                 

  

          



     :                #

     $       

-

 %

       

            

+         $        $)           $ ))                         $

 N  $)                  

         

     

L 3

      

   

    

   +                  N           +                $          +                    

 

 N  $                 >                       

                              

                

                 D .$)                    !"#   

          

        

          

   ; & $  L * ) L

* 

.$) $



.$))

$63)

   + $63)           .$)                       +    

         5        +        

          $  C+ $ 5)  $ 6))          !"#              +    

& $  L * ) L .$)



*  53



.$) $



.$))



L

*







.$) $



.$))

$6 )

     +       7            !"# $  C+ $ '))

       !"         #           Æ          #        ?@"   

       7  

                               +  5             

   

   5 

 $ --3) 

    !                   +                                   

                    

          .  

  $          56  ) ,               $)      :/                  ;  L /  .     

           Æ                    L 3 -                  #  

                    L 3   :/





                       

                 

"

 # $       % 

         63        

       +

0             &  $)(  $)     

         &  $)(       .  5 '  $)  3 ' 66   5



   3





4                   5                           33 +          !  +    33 +    +

                                     O     33Q 33L 3333                       +    ! 5                            . +                     +     

                           ,         $    3  )       +            5363R                    $   % & '()                 ,              7   +    #                +            +  ,       

           >                          +                            ! 6  /     +      4        $    )      3            

        



                            



            

       2               B                                  3 +

        ;  

       7                 

&  ;     

            K   @ .' 55

       Æ     $  "    )<                    $ C+ $

 $ ))

     $ 

)    )                   



                       

 +    ! 5 B          

 $ )

           %          N   $                  * O                                      

          ! 6                

      !            +

   -3R      +    . + !              S 

      53R       0      =     :3R                   . +   -/R                                #   *    8&6 ( !  4 &59(  % & '(                                               $  ! /) 4                                             

"

%& ' # (  (  

 

                                  

               #   % & '(                        >                                             56

       

  6                

               . +      %                                       

             

          ;   

                 

   

                             

               

   %                   

                                       

           

   C              

                                % +           

     $             )           ,                              

              ,                           B                

       0                       S            2                         B                               *                   C             

                   % +                                      

5/



          +  ;             Æ                                                                        ?                                     ! :  ' 

                                                     +                                          #                        

 



 7                         +  

"

'  & )  

 

                             

 !"#      +     

         ,                     !"#              + 

   *       !"# 

                                           $/ )       5'6   3

    

          

                             339  359 ! 9                       

             

           

       

                    63R     

5:

 + 

         ' + #  

 +   

                        

      

    

 *                                                                          T B     

                                   !"#        >    

                                          

                                          

 

             

              % +                             !"#       B          IJ               

  

   ! .         

      %                            <        %   & 9(                  #           5 

 

              +                5  '     #                                            +     ! -

                 

                          ! 9 #      ! 3             

         +  +

5'

     

   3R      . +    % +                        9 +                                                   $! 9)

        

                       . + 

               

     

         

       

          

    $ )           4               $C+ $

))       

             

 #                                3 +     +                      

       

          



    0   

         +       



$#    &:()                  

  



    +     

#     /   

        $    )              $     )               39R           

                                        

"

' 

                    !              7             2              7                   L 3              #B"#   $   5)

                / 59

%                         9         +             3  

                

                3 + 

     

                           4                          +     #                                                    +                                   #     

                    +              

                 

                  

                                 #                 

        7                                       ?

                            

                   

  2                    

                                                     

           

   C 

                     

                  N          !

      

      

  : >

  

                

5.

     

           

        353R $   5363R      )                            

                 

     + 

                                                                   ;  L /  .   $?

           .  )

                    :      

                  

                

                              L 3                 



 

                 +                          

            

                                                          

                               +              

  

   +             

                       

                     

              ,                         7       

5-

        

                   *                                             



                 +                                 #                                                              Æ    !"#                    

          

          7          +      +                     +         !"#           7          

      

 

                     

                   Æ                                

      Æ                                         Æ                  

                     

63

  ; C  1     C 

4 C

  Æ $ )        $ )     $Æ )  $3))    $    $)     $ ) !      $)

396 U 33 /U 3 .U 666 U  999U :99U 9  U

336' 333 335 3.. 33: 3 3 99 6

  3  Æ $ )    Æ $ )     3 $ )          $ )

335-U 33 3U 36'9U

63/ 3/ 333:

3569U

333.

  3 $" )   $" )

3 /'U 333.

333 33 '

$! $  % !$% &  "  '

   ("   '

$     (  "'

 &% $  % !$%))    ( *   " '

    $ )

   

   $N  ) Æ    $$)

4     $

 --3 

) 5      $) 33 "   $ ) 34        B ; U    + -' UU 4         

6

3 5

3 39 3

+(    '

  

3: 339

  5; C    C 1   

   $/ ) 5'6'U     $/ ) 33:     $/ ) 333'U 1           . L    B ; U   :R  UU   3R 

65

  353 33/3336   

  6; 0    %   ; >     > 1   1     > 1   1

  



                 

              ! "  

  

   

  #

            $       $  ! " 

  

   

  

  





#



          %& ' %& #' %&

   #

   #

  

  

         %& ' %& #' %&

  #

  #

  

 # 

              %& ' %& #' %&

   #

 #  

 ## 

# # #

       

    

             %&    ' %& ##    #' %&          ' ()  &  ' & "  *        *    

66

  

  /; 0    %   ; C  ?   C #     !

  

   + & 

 $  , - . /$$  0  , - .

              ! "  

#  

  

            $        $   ! "   

   

  







          %& ' %& #' %&

   #

   #

   #

         %& ' %& #' %&

  #

#  

  #

              %& ' %& #' %&

 #  

   

 #  

   

  

#  

       

    

             %& ' %& #' %&    *    

6/

  :; 0    %   ; 4  # 

  

   1 - -# ,-. 

              ! "  

  

  

            $        $   ! "   

  

  #   





 

          %& ' %& #' %&

   #

   

 # ##

  

         %& ' %& #' %&

  #

#  #

 # 

  

              %& ' %& #' %&

 #  

 #  

 ## #

  

             %& ' %& #' %&

   

  #

  

#  









       

    

          *    

6:

  

o -- brand-name + -- generic

Number of generic entrants

Price per patient day

1

.5

0

10

5

0 5

10

15

20

6

4

2

0 0

5

10

15

20

Total no. of patient days sold (million)

0

Brand-generic sales ratio (qb/qg)

15

0

5

10

15

20

0

5

10

15

20

55

50

45

40

Time since patent expired (quarter)

! ;       

6'

o Average of simulated data + Actual data

Price per patient day (1990 dollars)

Brand-name price

Generic price

.9

.3

.8 .2 .7 .1 .6

.5

0 0

5

10

15

20

0

Number of Patient Days (million)

Brand-name demand

5

10

15

20

10

15

20

Generic demand 40

40

30 30 20 20 10

10

0 0

5

10

15

20

0

5

Time since patent expired (quarter)

! 5; >     ;   + 

69

o price-sensitive consumers + price-insensitive consumers

Number of Patient Days (million)

20

15

10

5

0 0

5 10 15 Time since the patent expired (quarter)

20

! 6; 2     

Number of Patient Days (million)

20

15

10

5

0 0

5 10 15 Time since the patent expired (quarter)

! /; *     

6.

20

Brand-name price per patient day (1990 dollars)

o -- type 0

+ -- type 1 x -- original model

1

.8

.6

.4

.2 0

5

10 15 Time since patent expired (quarter)

20

! :; 2               

Proportion of brand-name sales accounted for by price-insensitive patients

1

.8

.6

.4 0

5

10 15 Time since patent expired (quarter)

20

! '; 1          

6-

Price per patient day (1990 dollars)

o Original Model + Experiment: increase entry probability Brand-name price

Generic price

.9

.3

.8 .2 .7 .1 .6 .5

0 0

5

10

15

20

0

Number of Patient Days (million)

Brand-name demand

5

10

15

20

10

15

20

Generic demand

40

30

30

20

20

10

10

0 0

5

10

15

20

0

5

Time since patent expired (quarter)

! 9;         ;   + 

/3

Expected return form submitting an application (million, 1990 dollars)

o Original Model

+ Experiment: increase entry probability

10

8

6

4

2

0 0

5 10 Number of firms applying for ANDA

15

! .; C      #B"#  

Number of generic entrants

15

10

5

0 0

5

10 15 Time since patent expired (quarter)

! -; # B    

/

20

Average predicted perceived variance of generics

o Original Model

+ Experiment

0

5

40

30

20

10

0 10 15 Time since patent expired (quarter)

20

! 3; #   ;        

/5

o Average of simulated data + Actual data

Price per patient day (1990 dollars)

Brand-name price

Generic price

.9

.3

.8 .2 .7 .1 .6

.5

0 0

5

10

15

20

0

Number of Patient Days (million)

Brand-name demand

5

10

15

20

10

15

20

Generic demand 40

40

30 30 20 20 10

10

0 0

5

10

15

20

0

5

Time since patent expired (quarter)

!

; >        ;   + 

/6

  & ( " #  #  D  %  %   C *  ; # 4 C C     C ? 5336 &5( " #    ?  O  1 "  "  %   ; C  1 C    0  C   "  C  2  O   5333 &6( 1   #  1 2  %    ,   2 E

 > D

C        :.$/);'5 S':/ E -9/ &/( 1   #  1 C    2 E

 "  "  D    C      6;: 9S:6- --6 &:( 4 #  #  1   E+ !     

        

1  --5

&'( % D 2 # "  #       0  % #  * 4   2   4 O   533  &9( " 2  E  8G G  "  

4 D 

       5.;996S9-: --9

&.( " 2  E  8G G C  8 " %  ! "   1 B 599 V  O   5333 &-( 4 2  # 1  C    1 , "  %     "  C  V  O   --- & 3( B 4 %

 8 % 4    C   D  "         ,       6; .:S5 6 --9 &

( B 8 %

 %  4   E C !  1 ?   1    7 * 4  2       

  53$ );6'S/9 -.'

& 5( B 8 %

 #  1 0  ?   2   * 4   

   

  5:$ );

3S 5  --  //

& 6( ?  C %     " 0     # , 1 C C   %    O4 1     ! "     

#

$     ; S/. -- 

& /( F4 %   F E         4 O   ,   5333 & :( # %  4 >     O4 1  "  # 1 C   "  C 

 >  4 O   533 

& '( # %  %  D  , ; "   "  1  "  # 1 C  "  C 

 >  4

O   5335 & 9( # %   * 

  B  2   

*  ? C  0  "  C 

 >  4

O   5335 & .( # % ,   %  * "  # 1  ?    1     %2> 4  %  2 >Æ E --. & -( * 4 %    4  O  C  1  "; #O  "   "  C  " O   5333 &53(  , "* %       *,

 B V -93 &5 ( *  C

   4 !  C

  4 C "    2   1     1  1 C  "  C    5333 &55(

 C     F # !#  1    ?     4  1 "    $"   65; S ' --:

&56(

  C    1 F "  O O ; % "  2 %  1        *   $"  :$ ); S53 --' /:

&5/( ?  C   # 1  1   "  ; # !  C  0        '5$ );:6S.6 --: &5:( %  !   # 1  #      

      B2C? 0 1 B '-6' --- &5'( ?  * !  " 4 4  1 1 D      1            :-$5); ':S 9- --5 &59( ?  * !  " 4 4  * C    1  1          $    '$ );9:S-3 --9

&5.( * *  # "    C ,     

     63;:'S.6 ---

&5-( * *   ? 

 "  C+      ,    

       $    5/;..:S.-/ --9

&63( , *    E  8 1    *  # 4    4  % &         3 ;/- S:5: -.9 &6 ( , *    E  8 2 D    C   1 %  1      -./ " #    '      6: --5 &65( , *    E  8 D 1    * %    O4;

 0, #  > "      3;

3S 56 --'

4  5 &66( W *     %  *  B *  1  1         5 6S 565 "  --/

&6/( E  , C  D   "1 "          '';59:S5.. --:

&6:( E ,  2 4 #         "   #    C   " "    :5;59 S653 -./

/'

&6'( * F

  4 ?   C   "  "* "   4 O   D4C --. &69( F E D     

(

  %   O  1  B V

-9  &6.( C    E   #   "  >  ;  @     :'$6);:/-S'33 -.. &6-( E 2    0

 > 2 * " ; %  1    1  1            

  /$ ); -5S53: -.3

&/3( # D 1 "      D    D?            9;66 S6/9 -./

&/ ( >    !"# ,  ,  4 O *" #       ! 

(  E 5336

&/5( # 1  1 * %  1 B C+  ; B      "  " 1           5:$/);:::S :.- --/ &/6( # 1  1 * 4   #  "   ;  1  C+      7%   "   7    '-$:); 5' S 5.5 4  533  &//( " ?    0 * "   "    "  #   %  C  O   

  !  5335 &/:(   ?    #

# 2

   1      

  -; .:S535 -9/

&/'( !  4  C "     * 1             63$6);/5 S//3 ---

/9

&/9( !  4  2  C  2 #   * C    O4 1     )     )  % * 

.; 3.:S

3/

5333 &/.( , " 4 E ? D  4 E 8



 C  7 1 

  ?   * > %        

    /$6);5:S6- --5

&/-( "%  4  4  0 4    0

 *  ?  4 , 

  E  # B  1

 2  # 1 C    1 

              -$5); 9S6  --. &:3( >Æ 

   #   O4 %  1  ? @ "; %  ?  

?  0  --6 &: ( 4 B 0  ?    1 %  1  ;

 %  

#   "  C   #@ O   >  --'

/.

Smile Life

When life gives you a hundred reasons to cry, show life that you have a thousand reasons to smile

Get in touch

© Copyright 2015 - 2024 PDFFOX.COM - All rights reserved.