Idea Transcript
Cookies on the BBC website The BBC has updated its cookie policy. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. This includes cookies from third party social media websites if you visit a page which contains embedded content from social media. Such third party cookies may track your use of the BBC website. We and our partners also use cookies to ensure we show you advertising that is relevant to you. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on the BBC website. However, you can change your cookie settings at any time.
Continue Change settings Find out more Search Home News
Sport
Weather
Shop
Earth
Travel ADVERTISEMENT
Home
Film
Music
Art
Books
NEW SECTION
FEATURED SERIES
Designed
The Art of Directing
Calendar
ADVERTISEMENT
.
.
.
.
.
.
By Mark Forsyth 8 September 2016
Over the weekend, I happened to go viral. Or rather a single paragraph from a book I wrote called The Elements of Eloquence went viral. The guilty paragraph went like this: “Adjectives in English absolutely have to be in this order: opinion-size-age-shape-colour-origin-material-purpose Noun. So you can have a lovely little old rectangular green French silver whittling knife. But if you mess with that word order in the slightest you’ll sound like a maniac. It’s an odd thing that every English speaker uses that list, but almost none of us could write it out.”
The Italian word with many meanings BBC Culture’s editor Matthew Anderson tweeted a passage from Mark Forsyth’s The Elements of Eloquence and it went viral (Credit: Matthew Anderson)
‘Dai’ explained by native speakers Language
English speakers love to learn this sort of thing for two reasons. First, it astonishes us that there are rules that we didn’t know that we knew. That’s rather peculiar, and rather exciting. We’re all quite a lot cleverer than we think we are. And there’s the shock of realising that there’s a reason there may be little green men on Mars, but there certainly aren’t green little men. Second, you can spend the next hour of your life trying to think of exceptions, which is useful as it keeps you from doing something foolish like working.
What your handwriting says about you
Actually, there are a couple of small exceptions. Little Red
The fascinating history of joined-up writing
Riding Hood may be perfectly ordered, but the Big Bad Wolf
Language
History
seems to be breaking all the laws of linguistics. Why does Bad Big Wolf sound so very, very wrong? What happened to the rules? Ding dong King Kong Well, in fact, the Big Bad Wolf is just obeying another great linguistic law that every native English speaker knows, but doesn’t know that they know. And it’s the same reason that you’ve never listened to hop-hip music. You are utterly familiar with the rule of ablaut reduplication. You’ve been
If somebody said ‘zag-zig’ or ‘cross-criss’ you would know they were breaking a rule
using it all your life. It’s just that you’ve never heard of it. But if
8 words that changed the way we think The cultural pioneers who coined new terms – from ‘serendipity’ to ‘Twitter’ Language
somebody said the words zag-zig, or ‘cross-criss you would know, deep down in your loins, that they were breaking a sacred rule of language. You just wouldn’t know
which one. All four of a horse’s feet make exactly the same sound. But we always, always say clip-clop, never clop-clip. Every second your watch (or the grandfather clock in the hall makes the same
Trump’s great exclamations!
sound) but we say tick-tock, never tock-tick. You will never eat
What overusing punctuation means
a Kat Kit bar. The bells in Frère Jaques will forever chime ‘ding dang dong’.
Language
Reduplication in linguistics is when you repeat a word, sometimes with an altered consonant (lovey-dovey, fuddyduddy, nitty-gritty), and sometimes with an altered vowel: bishbash-bosh, ding-dang-dong. If there are three words then the order has to go I, A, O. If there are two words then the first is I and the second is either A or O. Mish-mash, chit-chat, dillydally, shilly-shally, tip top, hip-hop, flip-flop, tic tac, sing song, ding dong, King Kong, ping pong.
Facebook
Twitter
“What about the Big Bad Wolf?” tweeted many naysayers. But they obviously didn’t know about the rule of ablaut reduplication (Credit: Alamy)
Why this should be is a subject of endless debate among linguists, it might be to do with the movement of your tongue or an ancient language of the Caucasus. It doesn’t matter. It’s the law, and, as with the adjectives, you knew it even if you didn’t know you knew it. And the law is so important that you just can’t have a Bad Big Wolf. Tense situations It’s astonishing quite how expert you are at the English language. There are so many tenses you can use without even thinking about it, and almost certainly without being able to name them. It depends how you count them, but there are about 20 that you deploy faultlessly. The pluperfect progressive passive for an extended state of action that happened to you prior to another action in the past is, when you put it like that,
The 21st Century’s 100 greatest films The best in cinema since 2000 as picked by 177 film critics The 100 greatest films of the 21st Century
rather daunting. But then you’d happily say “I realised I’d been being watched” without breaking sweat or blinking. Think how daunting this is for people learning English. The teacher has to explain to them that the English don’t usually use the present tense for things that are happening in the present. “I brush my teeth” doesn’t mean that you’re doing it right now, it just means that you do it regularly. For things that are actually happening right now you use the present progressive “I’m brushing my teeth” (but only if you can speak with your mouth full). And having learnt that you then have to learn that there are certain
We actually have a tense called the future present – imagine having to learn that
exceptions, like the verb ‘to think’ used as an auxiliary, as in “I think you’re right”. This is why,
Are these waxworks disgusting? When Venus was dissected Art history
incidentally, lots of non-native speakers will use phrases like “I am thinking that you are right”. It sounds faintly comic to us, but we
had years and years and years of immersion learning just to get all these subtleties. And English is complex and weird. We actually have a tense called the Future Present. Imagine having to learn that. But for us it’s just “The train leaves tomorrow.” Some rules we really should know. It’s surprising and dispiriting
The 10 most beautiful ceilings
how many English people don’t know the rules of stress,
Mosques, temples – and a golf club
because that’s how all our poetry works. It’s quite easy really, and we can hear it in other languages. Everyone knows that
Architecture
Italian has rhythm, it goes MAM-a MI-a BUON-a SER-a. But so does our language. And that’s how verse works. I can illustrate
ADVERTISEMENT
with my favourite limerick (or at least my favourite clean one). Try reading this aloud: There was a young man from Dundee Got stung on the leg by a wasp When asked does it hurt He said ‘Yes it does. ‘I’m so glad it wasn’t a hornet.’ That has no rhymes, but it still works as a limerick because rhymes aren’t nearly as important as rhythm. And the rhythm goes: de-DUM-de, de-DUM-de, de-DUM de-DUM-de, de-DUM-de, de-DUM de-DUM-de, de-DUM de-DUM-de, de-DUM de-DUM-de, de-DUM-de, de-DUM-de Which only works because we know to pronounce Dundee as ‘dun-DEE’,
In a strong French accent, there’s no difference between happiness and a penis
and not to rhyme with Grundy or the Isle of Lundy. It’s the subtle difference when we record a record or present a present or tell a rebel to rebel. It’s a difference that is very hard for people to learn, and is the main reason that, in a strong French
accent, there’s no difference between happiness and a penis. English is an immensely complicated language to get right, and native speakers often have no idea of its strangeness. We understand the sentence “I can’t put up with the guy I’m putting up at my house, his put-downs really put me out and I’m feeling put-upon”. Or “I’m doing up my house and it’s doing me in.” Literally, that should mean “I’m performing my house skywards and it’s performing me towards the interior”. These are called phrasal verbs and they are the nightmare of every would-be English speaker. Somebody once said of Ian Fleming that he got off with women because he couldn’t get on with them. To us that’s a simple joke, to a learner who also has to get through, get by, get down, get with it, get up… it does their head in. English is largely made up of the rules we don’t know that we know. And actually the rules we know we know are a rarity. We can cling to a few of them at least. At least we all know that we know that adjectives have comparatives and superlatives. Big, bigger, biggest. Hot, hotter, hottest. Easy, easier, easiest. It’s comforting. It’s reliable. It’s something we know that we know. But can you do it with an adjective that’s three syllables long? Curiouser and curiouser. Mark Forsyth is the author of The Elements of Eloquence: How to Turn the Perfect English Phrase If you would like to comment on this story or anything else you have seen on BBC Culture, head over to our Facebook page or message us on Twitter. And if you liked this story, sign up for the weekly bbc.com features newsletter, called “If You Only Read 6 Things This Week”. A handpicked selection of stories from BBC Future, Earth, Culture, Capital, Travel and Autos, delivered to your inbox every Friday.
.
.
.
.
.
.
TV shows to watch in 2018 From thrillers to comedy and foreign drama Television
The phrase that predicts love
Film review: All the Money in the World
‘Koi No Yokan’ is ‘the premonition of love’
Is Ridley Scott’s kidnap drama worth a watch?
Language
The most exciting music of 2018 Our pick of the best live shows, new albums and emerging talent
Film Reviews
Ten books to read in 2018
Ten films to watch in 2018
From short stories about Florida to an essay collection by Zadie Smith
Including the sequel to Mary Poppins and Margot Robbie as Elizabeth I
Books
Literature
Film Reviews
Pop music
Who will be remembered in 1,000 years?
The subtle bias that no-one talks about
Open offices are driving us mad
Taking 'snowflakes' seriously
What you don’t know about holiday cake
The Dutch city that’s more like Dubai
Explore the BBC
Home
News
Sport
Weather
Shop
Earth
Travel
Capital
Culture
Autos
Future
TV
Radio
CBBC
CBeebies
Food
iWonder
Bitesize
Music
Arts
Make It Digital
Taster
Nature
Local
Terms of Use
About the BBC
Privacy Policy
Cookies
Accessibility Help
Parental Guidance
Contact the BBC
Get Personalised Newsletters
Advertise with us
Ad choices
Copyright © 2018 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.