Idea Transcript
Menu
Your Daily Microdose of Genius
Your Daily Microdose of Genius Discover t Surprising Science Personal Growth Mind & Brain Sex & Relationships Technology & Innovation Culture & Religion Politics & Current Affairs
Surprising Science
New coating kills germs on hospital surfaces with light
by Robby Berman
Multivitamins are not only ineffective, but dangerous
by Derek Beres Experts t Featured Experts Van Jones Civil Rights Advocate and Political Commentator Host, 'The Messy Truth with Van Jones' Videos [16] Why is there a higher suicide rate in the spring? Articles [2] Michelle Thaller by Robby Berman Astronomy, Science Communication Assistant Director for Science Communication, NASA Videos [5] Steven Pinker Psychologist and Linguist Professor of Psychology, Harvard University Videos [32] Articles [1] Playlists t
VIDEO What’s your commitment? How to become an effect... What’s your commitment? How to become an effective change-maker.
Chelsea Clinton
1 VIDEO Learning is more than retaining information—how... Learning is more than retaining information—how mentors make the difference
Karim Abouelnaga
2 VIDEO How financial innovation is giving cities jobs,... How financial innovation is giving cities jobs, wealth and health
Donnel Baird
3 VIDEO How one Ugandan is fighting human trafficking i... How one Ugandan is fighting human trafficking in Africa—and the U.S.
Agnes Igoye 4 6-PART PLAYLIST
A new generation of leaders for new global challenges | Clinton Global Initiative University Start playlist Podcast
big think for business Search 15k+ videos, articles, experts Discover Surprising Science Personal Growth Mind & Brain Sex & Relationships Technology & Innovation Culture & Religion Politics & Current Affairs Experts Playlists Podcast Edge
LATEST CONNECT WITH US 'I believe because it is absurd': Christianity's first meme New cyberattack method steals data directly from power cords and grids The mystery of how birds navigate is over, and the answer is so amazing
Is Happiness for Shallow People? Over a year ago
by Lea Carpenter
In his piece in this week’s New Yorker on depression, and depression-related research, Louis Menand asks, “Is psychopharmacology evil, or is it useless?” Increasingly, skeptics say it’s the latter, and new tests telling us placebos are as effective as anti-depressants only bolster their view. But whether or not these drugs work, there is another, vastly less statistical, dilemma: if we’re all happy all the time (whatever that means) will we lose something—a feeling, a challenge, an intellectual asset—fundamental to life? Menand designs a simple, provocative test, an emotional one. He asks the reader to consider giving up grief. Grief, after all, has certain similarities to what physicians term depression. Yet unlike many modes of diagnosable depression—it also has a clear cause: loss. He writes: What if your sadness was grief, though? And what if there were a pill that relieved you of the physical pain of bereavement—sleeplessness, weeping, loss of appetite—without diluting your love for or memory of the dead? Assuming that bereavement “naturally” remits after six months, would you take a pill today that will allow you to feel the way you will be feeling six months from now anyway? Probably most people would say no. Is this because of what the psychiatrist Gerald Klerman once called “pharmacological Calvinism”? Klerman was describing the view, which he thought many Americans hold, that shortcuts to happiness are sinful, that happiness is not worth anything unless you have worked for it. (Klerman misunderstood Calvinist theology, but never mind.) We are proud of our children when they learn to manage their fears and perform in public, and we feel that we would not be so proud of them if they took a pill instead, even though the desired outcome is the same. We think that sucking it up, mastering our fears, is a sign of character. But do we think that people who are naturally fearless lack character? We usually think the opposite. Yet those people are just born lucky. Why should the rest of us have to pay a price in dread, shame, and stomach aches to achieve a state of being that they enjoy for nothing? Or do we resist the grief pill because we believe that bereavement is doing some work for us? Maybe we think that since we appear to have been naturally selected as creatures that mourn, we shouldn’t short-circuit the process. Or is it that we don’t want to be the kind of person who does not experience profound sorrow when someone we love dies? Questions like these are the reason we have literature and philosophy. No science will ever answer them. Amen. Earlier in the piece, Menand makes this beautiful (his always are) metaphor: Science, particularly medical science, is not a skyscraper made of Lucite. It is a field strewn with black boxes. The box labeled “the brain” will be the hardest to recover.
Sponsored Content
The Add-on Every New Car Needs | Erie Insurance Blog
On the Horizon: Better Seat Belts for Seniors
Ireland Was Made for Your Spring Vacation
Erie Insurance
Ireland.com
How This Expert-Designed App Can Teach You Spanish In 3 Weeks
[Gallery] These are the Toughest Female Soldiers in the World
Why 11% of industry 4.0 Global VC Funding goes to Israel
Babbel
Bob's Hideout
Startup Nation Central Blog
Erie Insurance
Recommended by
MOST POPULAR How to disagree well: 7 of the best and worst ways to argue Jesus wasn't white: he was a brown-skinned, Middle Eastern Jew. Here's why that matters For thousands of years, humans slept in two shifts. Should we do it again?
Dare to Think Bigger Sign up to get more stories like this in your inbox What Was “Female Hysteria,” Really? Enter email address * Subscribe RELATED
'I believe because it is absurd': Christianity's first meme
by Peter Harrison
How a 4th-century Taoist concept is treating anxiety
by Derek Beres
Why Christianity has been pushed underground in China
by Derek Beres
7 famous siblings who have changed history
by Scotty Hendricks
We'd rather have fair inequality than unfair equality, research shows
by Derek Beres
Saudi Arabia to end its 35-year cinema ban with screening of ‘Black Panther’
by Stephen Johnson
How much does it matter whether God exists?
by Nathan Schneider
Why does the conspiracy theory of Martin Luther King's assassination persist?
by Brandon A. Weber
Follow Us
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter Enter email address Subscribe About Us Advisors Contact Us Partner With Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use © Copyright 2007-2018 & BIG THINK, BIG THINK EDGE, SMARTER FASTER trademarks owned by The Big Think, Inc. All rights reserved.
Big Think Edge helps organizations by catalyzing conversation around the topics most critical to 21st century business success. Led by the world’s foremost experts, our dynamic learning programs are short-form, mobile, and immediately actionable. Find out more
Shares